This study provides a comparative analysis of messaging across digital and traditional communication channels, prompting customers to reduce “Peak Power” consumption. The alert was framed through simulated treatments on an energy bill, in text message, though email, on a company webpage, and through Twitter, Facebook and Instagram posts. Perception of messages were measured for Creativity, Clarity and Credibility. Instagram elicited the highest scores from respondents (N = 391). The lowest ranking media platform was text messaging. Exploratory factor analysis confirmed two dimensions among the platforms, the powerful “Visual Energy Messaging” (Energy bill, Instagram, Facebook, Website) and the weaker “Word Based Energy Messaging” (Twitter, Email and Text). Implications for practitioners indicate visual messaging is most effective, using a cross-pollination technique sharing specific messages across visual platforms. Special attention should be paid to the consumption habits of older consumers who may receive and interpret messaging in a different context.